Key Takeaways:
- The American Gold Eagle is considered to be the most popular piece ever produced in the U.S.
- The American Gold Buffalo was the first pure 24-karat gold coin available to purchase.
- Gold is a great inflation hedge because banks can’t control its supply like they can control traditional forms of currency.
Gold is a reliable asset that can be a great addition to a portfolio, but which gold pieces are right for you depends on your preferences and long-term financial goals.
In this article, you’ll learn about the history and specifications of the American Gold Eagle and American Gold Buffalo coins, their value, the benefits of purchasing gold, and how to include it in your portfolio.
The American Gold Eagle
The American Gold Eagle, first minted in 1986, is currently produced at the West Point Mint in New York. It was minted following the passage of the Gold Bullion Coin Act of 1985. The primary goal of this act was to provide a government-backed gold product the public could rely on.
Since its inception, the public sentiment surrounding the American Gold Eagle has been overwhelmingly positive. This coin is considered to be the most popular piece ever produced in the United States.
The original Gold Eagle coin dates back to 1792, but production was halted a couple of centuries later. Franklin D. Roosevelt signed Executive Order 6102 into law on April 5, 1933, making it illegal to privately own most forms of gold. The goal of this decree was to help prevent banks from going bankrupt during the Great Depression.
Specifications
The American Gold Eagle is 91.67% pure gold, which makes it a 22-karat piece. It also has an alloy mix of 5.33% copper and 3.00% silver. These metals help protect the coin from scratches and other types of wear and tear. For sizes, you can find the American Gold Eagle in either a ⅒ ounce, ¼ ounce, ½ ounce, or one ounce.
On the front, you’ll find a full-length version of Lady Liberty holding a torch and olive branch. For the back, there are two variations. You may find the original (1986-2021), a bald eagle carrying an olive branch to a nest that holds a mother eagle and her babies. You may also find the most current version (2021-present), which is a close-up portrait of a bald eagle’s head.
Value
American Gold Eagle coins have both a face value and metal content value. A coin’s face value is the number on the front; a coin’s metal value is how much its metal mix is worth.
| Coin Size | Face Value | Metal Value |
| ⅒ ounce | $5 | $415.51 |
| ¼ ounce | $10 | $1,038.77 |
| ½ ounce | $25 | $2,077.54 |
| one ounce | $50 | $4,155.08 |
Note that a coin’s value may not always align with its price, as metal market prices are always changing due to various external factors. A piece could be worth thousands and priced far below or above that following an economic shift.
Why Does the IRS Make an Exception for It?
The American Gold Eagle is only 91.67% pure, and despite not meeting the IRS standard of 99.5%, it can still be held in a precious metals IRA. When Congress passed the Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997, it included language exempting the Gold Eagle coin from being held to that standard.
The American Gold Buffalo
The American Gold Buffalo, first minted on June 22, 2006, was the first pure 24-karat gold coin available to purchase. Like the Gold Eagle, this coin is also struck at the West Point Mint in New York. Its design is inspired by the Buffalo nickel, which was produced from 1913-1938.
Congress approved the production of the American Gold Buffalo under the Presidential $1 Coin Act of 2005 in an effort to compete with existing 24-karat bullion coins.
Specifications
The American Gold Buffalo coin is 99.99% pure gold, so it contains no other metals or alloys. For size, typically only one-ounce coins are available to purchase. This has been the primary size produced each year by the U.S. Mint since the coin’s inception.
In 2008, ⅒-ounce, ¼-ounce, and ½-ounce sizes were minted, but since production ended that same year, these may be more difficult to come by. On the front of the coin, you’ll find a detailed portrait of a Native American person. On the back, you’ll find an American buffalo.
Value
Just like the American Gold Eagle, American Gold Buffalo coins have both a face value and metal value.
| Coin Size | Face Value | Metal Value |
| ⅒ ounce | $5 | $415.51 |
| ¼ ounce | $10 | $1,038.77 |
| ½ ounce | $25 | $2,077.54 |
| one ounce | $50 | $4,155.08 |
Note that a coin’s value may not always align with its price, as metal market prices are always changing due to various external factors. A piece could be worth thousands and priced far below or above that following an economic shift.
The Benefits of Purchasing Gold
Gold is known to be an asset that holds firm, even during uncertain times. This makes it an excellent choice for a retirement portfolio.
Inflation Protection
Gold is a great inflation hedge because banks can’t control its supply like they can control traditional forms of currency. Money can be printed as often as the government and banks want.
These entities can deliberately increase the amount of money in circulation so that its purchasing power decreases. This is called currency debasement.
Gold supply cannot be manipulated in this way, which makes it less vulnerable and more equipped to hold its value over an extended period of time.
Portfolio Diversification
The more diverse a portfolio is, the less susceptible it is to market risk. Market conditions that cause one asset to fail may not affect another at all. Having diverse holdings means that even if an asset or two underperforms, you’ll still have others to lean on.
Easy Liquidity
Gold is globally recognized and has high liquidity. Liquidity refers to how easily an asset can be sold for cash without affecting its market price. Not all assets are easy to liquidate, but because of gold’s history and reputation, the process is much simpler.
How To Include Gold In Your Portfolio
If you want to include gold in your retirement portfolio, you’ll need to have the proper account setup. Not all retirement accounts can hold precious metals. You’ll need a Gold IRA, Roth Gold IRA, or SEP Gold IRA.
Precious Metals IRA
A Gold IRA, also called a precious metals IRA, is a self-directed account that can help retirement planners by allowing them to tie their savings to metals like gold, silver, platinum, and palladium. Not all metal pieces are eligible, the IRS has strict rules surrounding which ones can be held in your portfolio.
Acquire Gold Coins With AHG
American Hartford Gold has a variety of gold products for clients to choose from. If you’re purchasing gold for the first time, our dedicated team is ready to help you get started picking out eligible pieces or opening a Gold IRA.
Gold has been a trusted safe haven for centuries, and when it comes to retirement, finding trustworthy assets is important. You can even include eligible silver, platinum, and palladium pieces. Fill out the intake form to get started.
FAQs
Why is the American Gold Eagle exempt from IRS standards?
The American Gold Eagle, despite only being 91.67% pure, can still be held in a precious metals IRA. This is because Congress passed the Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997, which exempted the coin from being held to the same standard as other gold products.
How many pieces of gold should I buy for my portfolio?
Precious metal assets held in a portfolio are measured by the portfolio’s weight, not by the number of pieces. It’s typically recommended to allocate 5% to 15% of a portfolio to gold for the best results.
Every portfolio has a different balance, so to determine how much gold to purchase to match the recommended percentage, divide your portfolio’s total value by the current market price of a single gold bar.
What is the difference between a coin’s value and its price?
A coin’s value is how much it’s worth, including its face value and metal content value. This means a coin only marked “50” could be worth thousands due to its alloy mix. A coin’s price is what it goes for on the market, and this figure may be above or below its actual worth depending on economic factors such as supply and demand or public sentiment.
How do I know if a coin dealer is legitimate?
You can verify the legitimacy of a coin dealer based on a variety of factors. Many reputable dealers, like American Hartford Gold, have the following:
- Accreditation: American Hartford Gold has maintained an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau since 2016.
- Reviews: American Hartford Gold has a 4.8/5 star rating on Trustpilot from nearly 2,000 verified clients.
- Recognition: American Hartford Gold has been on the Inc. 5000 list of fastest-growing private companies.
- Traceability: American Hartford Gold is registered as a business entity in California, with our HQ located at 11755 Wilshire Blvd in Los Angeles.
- Buyback: American Hartford Gold has a buyback program where, if they purchase your metals back, they won’t charge any liquidation fees.
Not every dealer is on a recognized list or offering a buyback program. However, at minimum, it’s a good sign if a dealer is accredited and has public testimonials along with an easily traceable business footprint.
Sources:
S.1639 – Gold Bullion Coin Act of 1985 | Congress
H.R.2014 – Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 | Congress
Understanding Currency Debasement: Definition and Historical Examples | Investopedia
Understanding Liquidity and How to Measure It | Investopedia
Investments in collectibles in individually directed qualified plan accounts | IRS






