12 Rarest Coins Wanted by Collectors

Rare coins often become the subject of intrigue and fascination among coin collectors. These sought-after treasures aren’t just pieces of precious metal — they’re fragments of history and craftsmanship tied to various eras and locations.

In the captivating world of numismatics (the study and collection of currency), collectors search for valuable items to add to their collections. Among those that have achieved almost legendary status are the 12 rarest coins, each with a unique story and significance. From the 1919-D Walking Liberty Half Dollar to the curious Sacagawea Cheerios Dollar, these 12 coins capture the art of minting and the passion for collecting.

1. 1919-D Walking Liberty Half Dollar

Minted At: Denver Mint

The 1919-D Walking Liberty Half Dollar is a rare coin with an obverse design that features Lady Liberty with flowing hair — an iconic symbol of freedom.

This coin is considered rare due to low mintage and fewer surviving examples. The half-dollar design is a classic that many numismatists covet. Its depiction of Liberty resonates with core American values.

2. 1895 Proof Morgan Dollar

Minted At: Philadelphia Mint

The 1895 Proof Morgan Dollar is a Morgan Silver Dollar with a Liberty Head on the obverse

It is one of the rarest silver dollars in U.S. coinage, with only 880 ever minted. A must-have for Morgan Silver Dollar enthusiasts, it often reaches high values on eBay and other auction sites.

3. 1909-S VDB Lincoln Cent

Minted At: San Francisco Mint

With a Lincoln head on the obverse and initials VDB for Victor David Brenner, the designer, on the reverse side, the 1909-S VDB Lincoln Cent was only available for a short time, making it one of the most valuable coins.

This penny is a gem for Lincoln cent enthusiasts, and its rarity makes it highly sought after by coin collectors.

4. 1794 Flowing Hair Silver Dollar

Minted At: Philadelphia Mint

With Lady Liberty with flowing hair on the obverse, the 1794 Flowing Hair Silver Dollar is one of the first silver coins produced by the U.S. Mint. An uncirculated example of this silver dollar was once auctioned for over $10 million, representing the history and rarity of early U.S. coins.

5. 1893 Morgan Silver Dollar

Minted At: Various, including Philadelphia and San Francisco Mint

The 1893 Morgan Silver Dollar is another version of the Morgan Silver Dollar, showcasing the Liberty Head. It has become rare due to low mintage numbers in specific years, and this coin’s value can range widely depending on condition and mint mark.

6. Buffalo Nickels

Minted At: Various mints, including Denver Mint

Buffalo Nickels feature an American Indian head on the obverse and a buffalo on the reverse, and some specific years and mint marks are incredibly scarce.

Numismatists treasure collectible coins like the rare Buffalo Nickels with doubled die errors.

7. 1921 Peace Dollar

Minted At: Philadelphia Mint

The 1921 Peace Dollar features the Liberty head on the obverse, and an eagle on the reverse with the inscription “In God We Trust.”

Minted for just one year, this high-relief coin is one of the rarest U.S. coins, and it is known for its beautiful design, symbolizing peace after World War I.

8. 1932-D Washington Quarter

Minted At: Denver Mint

The 1932-D Washington Quarter features President George Washington’s profile, and is rare due to low mintage, especially with the “D” mint mark.

Washington Quarters like this one are essential for collectors, and finding one in pocket change would be a remarkable discovery.

9. 1982 Roosevelt Dime (No Mint Mark Error)

Minted At: Supposed to be Philadelphia, but lacks the mint mark.

The 1982 Roosevelt Dime features President Franklin Roosevelt on the obverse, and error coins with no mint mark are highly unusual.

Roosevelt dimes like this delight collectors looking for error coins.

10. 1848 CAL Liberty Head Quarter Eagle

Minted At: Philadelphia Mint

This gold coin features the Liberty head on the obverse, and it commemorates the California Gold Rush with the “CAL” stamp above the eagle.

This is one of the rarest gold coins, eagerly sought by coin collectors

11. 1933 Indian Head Gold Eagle

Minted At: Philadelphia Mint

This coin features an Indian Head on the obverse and an eagle on the reverse, and almost all were melted down during the Gold Confiscation Act. This coin is highly valuable for its rarity and historical significance. These gold coins are the pinnacle for many collectors.

12. Sacagawea Cheerios Dollar

Minted At: Various

Sacagawea, the Shoshone woman who helped Lewis and Clark, is pictured on the obverse of this coin, which was initially released in Cheerios cereal boxes, making it an uncommon find. Unique in its introduction and collectible value, it holds a special place among U.S. coins.

These coins represent various styles, histories, and values. From silver dollars to Lincoln pennies, these treasures offer a glimpse into the rich heritage of American coinage.

When Is a Coin Considered Rare?

A coin rarity is based on factors that make it scarce, unique, or highly desirable. Here’s a breakdown of what typically contributes to a coin’s rarity:

  1. Mintage Numbers: Coins produced in limited quantities are often considered rare. Low mintage numbers mean fewer copies of that coin exist, making them harder to find.
  2. Surviving Examples: Many coins get lost, melted down, or worn beyond recognition. The number of surviving examples in good condition can contribute to a coin’s rarity.
  3. Errors and Varieties: Sometimes, coins are minted with errors or variations in design, die, or planchet. These anomalies can make them more attractive to collectors.
  4. Demand: Rarity is not just about scarcity but also desirability. Highly-sought coins, even if not particularly scarce, can be considered rare if the demand outstrips supply.
  5. Historical Significance: Coins tied to historical events or figures can be considered rare, primarily if produced for a limited time or in restricted areas.
  6. Condition: A common coin in extraordinary condition can become rare. The coin’s grading plays a significant role, with higher grades often being scarcer.
  7. Provenance: Sometimes, a coin’s previous ownership or unique story can add to its rarity. Coins that were part of famous collections or have an exciting history are more sought after.
  8. Age: While age alone doesn’t make a coin rare, older coins are more likely to have been lost or damaged, so exceptional examples can be harder to find.

When seeking rare coins, it’s vital to do your research and consult reputable sources. Verify the coin’s authenticity, and consider having it graded by professional services like PCGS (Professional Coin Grading Services) to understand its value.

Building relationships with reputable coin dealers and other collectors can also guide your quest for these pieces of history. Whether you’re a beginner looking for coins worth money or a seasoned collector hunting for the rarest treasures, you’ll find the world of numismatics offers endless opportunities for exploration and enjoyment.

How To Know What Your Coins Are Worth

Evaluating your coin’s value can be an intricate and multifaceted process, often requiring a blend of research, professional guidance, and market understanding.

As you search, here are a few ways to tell if your coin is valuable:

1. Identify the Coin

Determine the type of coin (e.g., penny, nickel, dollar coin), and look for the year it was minted as well as the mark indicating where it was minted (e.g., “S” for San Francisco Mint).

2. Determine the Condition

Coins are graded from “poor” to “mint state.” Evaluating the coin’s condition accurately can be challenging, so it might be worth consulting a professional grading service like PCGS.

It’s also best toassess how worn the coin is, looking for scratches, dents, or other damage.

3. Check Rarity Factors

Look for information about how many coins of that type were minted, and check if the coin has historical value or unique characteristics.

You should also look for any minting errors or variations that might increase the coin’s value.

4. Consult Reference Materials

Use coin price guides available online or in print to find average values for coins of similar type, date, mint mark, and condition.

Look at recent auction results for similar coins to gauge current market value — some websites even offer free tools to estimate your coin’s value based on its characteristics.

5. Consider Professional Appraisal

Reputable coin dealers can provide an expert opinion on your coin’s value, and some auction houses provide valuation services, especially if you intend to sell through them.

Sending your coin to a grading service can also provide an accurate and professional assessment.

6. Factor in Demand

Consider the current interest and market trends in coin collecting. Are people particularly interested in the type of coin you have?

If your coin contains gold or silver, the current market value of those metals will also impact its worth, and the broader economy can influence the coin market, impacting buyers’ willingness to pay.

7. Understand Selling Options

Consider the fees involved if you plan to market online or through an auction, and be prepared to negotiate if selling to a dealer or individual.

Remember that a coin’s value can vary based on who buys it, where you sell it, and how you market it. Whether you’re a novice just beginning to explore the world of numismatics or an experienced collector looking to expand your assets, understanding the worth of your coins is an essential and satisfying part of the coin-collecting journey.

The Bottom Line

The world of coin collecting is filled with intrigue, history, and the pursuit of rare treasures. From identifying the rarest coins sought after by collectors to understanding where to find these gems and how to ascertain their actual value, the journey into numismatics is both challenging and rewarding.

Coins tell stories of our past, represent pieces of art and craftsmanship, and often hold financial value that can grow over time. There’s always more to learn and discover for both amateurs and seasoned collectors, from silver dollars to Jefferson nickels.

If your passion has ignited a desire to obtain precious metals such as gold and silver bullion, consider turning to a trusted partner in the industry. American Hartford Gold is a leader in helping individuals acquire physical gold and silver. With a reputation for integrity, expertise, and personalized service, American Hartford Gold can guide you in expanding your horizons beyond rare coins into the broader world of precious metal ownership.


Rare Coin Values: How To Tell If Your U.S. Coin Is Valuable | U.S. Coins Guide

CoinFacts Rarity Scale™ | PCGS 

Understanding Coin Grading Basics | American Numismatic Association

Coin Production | U.S. Mint

Get Your Free 2024 Guide
Most Recent News